Hi all,
So interesting to see the responses begin to filter in.
I think of valerian and Passiflora quite differently. By the way, my use of capitals is intentional - we use lowercase for valerian because that is the common name for the plant, but Passiflora gets a capital because we usually use the proper Latin name for that plant, rather than calling it passionflower.
I digress!!
Valerian is a strong plant - the closest to a sedative we get in herbal medicine as some of you experience when you had to reduce the dose. Although I should point out that plants canāt force sedation as a pharmaceutical does, but it has a strong action and itās too much for some people.
A very few people will actually find that valerian makes them feel agitated. It is usually a specific constitutional type of person (we think - more on that as we look at our findings from S1 ). What I experience of Valerian in clinic is that it requires that you allow it to help you. If you are the kind of person who absolutely cannot let go, it is unlikely to be your plant.
Essentially, you are going to know when youāve taken valerian. It is not subtle.
Passiflora is a whole other kind of medicine. It is airy, subtle, diffuse. It doesnāt smell of stinky socks like our friend valerian. It sidles up to you like you would approach a wild animal and slowly begins to influence the body. You may not even notice at first.
If you think about the way it grows, it is a vine that can become invasive as it searches for nooks and crannies to enter. But for all that it is delicate and beautiful- this plant can make it through concrete! Never mistake delicacy for a sign of weakness!
In clinic then, Passiflora is the herb I give to anyone with disturbed sleep patterns and I watch for material change to unfold over time. If the patient has any anxiety it is absolutely indicated too, some herbalists use it for any anxiety, I only reach for it when the anxiety is related to insomnia (or insomnia for any other reason).
I hope that helps give you a flavour of these two amazing herbs!